Angels and Pins

Gotrek-and-Felix-4-C-formatThis column was originally a Night Bazaar weekly topic that asked all the Night Shade authors to examine the following topic: “Lightspeed vs. Landlock – Intergalactic Travel vs Mundane Fantasy.” I wasn’t honestly sure if I was supposed to contrast these two things, pick one over the other, or what, so I just ran with my first impression and made some shit up.

The first thing the topic called to mind was my time writing tie-in fiction for the Warhammer table-top battle games. Now, I don’t know if you’re familiar with the games, but Warhammer comes in exactly two flavors. You have Warhammer Fantasy, which is basically humans, elves, dwarfs, orcs and gribbly chaos beasties all running around in a fantasy version of early renaissance Germany, or you have Warhammer 40,000, which is basically humans, elves, orcs and gribbly chaos beasties (no dwarfs – for some reason the poor wee bastards never made it off planet) all running around in a gothic, Imperial Rome meets the thousand-year-reich version of space opera.

I always wrote on the fantasy side of the Warhammer coin. I’m just more at home with swords and spells than with bolt guns and spaceships, but I loved the lore of 40k (as they call it) just as much as I did Warhammer Fantasy. The fans of Warhammer fiction, however, were constantly arguing in the forums over which setting was better. This is fairly standard forum behavior, and I generally paid it no mind, but one of the arguments the 40k guys wielded against the Fantasy guys struck me as sillier than average.

“Fantasy is too limited!” they would say. “It’s just one world! In 40k there is an entire galaxy to explore, with thousands of worlds. Millions!”

Which leads me to the allusion I make in the title of this post. How many angels can dance on the head of a pin? How many villages can you fit into an imaginary country? How many caves can you fit into a fictitious mountain range? How many unexplored cellars can you fit into an invented medieval city? How many taverns? How many secret cults? How many heroes and villains?

The answer is, of course, as many as you want – an infinite amount. I invented new towns and new locations for every Warhammer book I wrote. I invented what I needed, and found a place to squeeze it all in around the already existing bits. The point, of course, is that scale in science fiction and fantasy is just frosting, just like the difference between swords and blasters or magic and high tech. Lightyears equal years. Planets equal countries. Vast, starless voids equal vast, trackless mountain ranges. Spaceport bars equal village taverns. The worlds of fantasy and science fiction are equally infinite, equally capable of accommodating any size story. And if you want some proof of the elasticity of an apparently contained setting, have a look at literary fiction.

Twenty centuries on, and the clever fucks who write that stuff still haven’t run out of stories to tell set on that one tiny little planet they call Earth.

Tags »

Date: Sunday, 19. May 2013 13:00
Trackback: Trackback-URL Category: Warhammer, Writing

Feed for the post RSS 2.0 Comment this post


  1. 1

    Just finished the Blackhearts collection. The book should be available as an ebook but does not seem to be so.

    The religious theme is a lot more powerful in 40k.

  2. 2

    I asked BL about a Blackhearts ebook. They say they’ll get around to it eventually.

    True about religion in 40k.

  3. 3

    Thanks for your response. While I’m at it… re: Ending of the Gotrek Saga.

    I think it is a grave mistake to confuse “ending the saga” with “no more new Gotrek stories”.

    Elric’s doom was published in 1964, yet new stories followed after that.

    The Warhammer Fantasy concept is that of a doomed world, and Gotrek is part of the soul of this world.

    The recent Reynolds book is ok, however I think BL got it wrong when they set the Fantasy equivalent to the Horus Heresy in the past — what they should do is embark on a massive, concerted, Horus Heresy scale project to define the END of the Warhammer world.

  4. 4

    Review by Zenik for Rating: Blackhearts is an entertaining story that weaevs a tale about a group of criminals turned soldiers, and is entertaining to the last page. Nathan Long does a great job of balancing action with character development, and it is truly a funny book. Trust me, you will laugh. It’s a good read, and I recommend it to those who are fans of fantasy, with a bit of humor.

Submit comment